unnamed

Labor says study proves ending prevailing wage was a mistake (WV)

By MetroNews
May 21, 2019 at 2:07 PM

CHARLESTON, W.Va. – The organization which represents skilled tradesmen in West Virginia believes a new study out of the University of Missouri-Kansas City is clear evidence the removal of the prevailing wage requirement in West Virginia was a mistake.

The Affiliated Construction Trades Foundation released the findings from the Midwest Economic Policy Institute which examined West Virginia’s state funded construction costs three years after the legislature eliminated a requirement for payment of a prevailing wage on state funded construction jobs.

“The report finds there has been no savings,” said ACT Foundation Executive Director Steve White on MetroNews Talkline. “This experiment to bring savings has failed.”

Supporters of the removal of the prevailing wage requirement claimed the action would enable to the state to enjoy enough savings to build five new schools for the cost of three. White said the data from the study found quite the opposite. He said the study found no savings to taxpayers, despite diminished wages for the laborers on the job.

“Building four schools for the price of three or five for the price of three would be a 25 percent savings,” White said. “It’s totally untrue.”

White said many of their members have lost not only wages, but also lost benefits because of the provision’s removal.

“When you compare it to surrounding states, they’ve lost even more,” he said. “The folks in surrounding states that have prevailing wage have seen modest increases. You’ve seen huge cuts in wages and benefits.”

White and his organization plan to use the data to build their case for the legislature to reinstate the prevailing wage law in the next legislative session. White said the provision has done more harm than good, despite what it was touted to have been in the beginning.

“We want good paying jobs and we want people to have good benefits,” he said. “There’s also cost to the taxpayer when people are not paid and not productive and don’t have those benefits.”

(Read More)

(See PDF of Study)

 

3d_money_construction_dreamstime_xxl_21903206

New West Virginia study finds repeal of prevailing wage saved taxpayers no money (WV)

by Jake Jarvis
May 21, 2019

CHARLESTON – Officials with the West Virginia State Building Trades Council and Affiliated Construction Trades say lawmakers should consider reinstating the prevailing wage law in light of a new study.

The study, published this month by a researcher from Missouri University and the Midwest Policy Institute, found that repeal of the prevailing wage law “had negative impacts for West Virginia’s construction workers, contractors and communities while failing to deliver any meaningful cost savings.”

Steve White, director of the ACT, said in a press conference Tuesday afternoon that the promised results of repealing the prevailing wage law have not been realized.

The law required that workers on state-funded construction projects be paid a so-called prevailing wage, which was calculated by state officials after determining the usual pay rate on such projects in West Virginia.

Proponents of repealing the 1933 law said it would reduce construction costs, but opponents said repealing it would allow out-of-state companies to come to West Virginia and undercut companies here by bidding far below them.

Luther Lasure, director of the Kanawha Valley Builders Association, said that’s exactly what happened.

He said there have been more out-of-state contractors winning bids for state-funded projects. And he said said those out-of-state companies don’t have as much of an incentive to do quality work, since they don’t actually live in the community.

Lasure said that, as uncomfortable as it is to admit it in a press conference full of union officials and supporters, he’s a member of the Republican Party, the party that repealed the prevailing wage. Despite this, he said he believes in listening to the data and the data shows the repeal has hurt workers.

“The taxpayers are not saving any money, but wages have been cut dramatically,” White said.

White called on legislative leaders to “correct course” and reverse the “terrible mistake” they enacted with repealing prevailing wage in 2015.

(Read More)

The impact of repealing prevailing wage laws on military veterans

Abdur Chowdhury, Professor, Department of Economics, Marquette University
February 1, 2017

Prevailing wage laws have been the focus of public policy debate in the United States for some time now. …

The prevailing wage concept arises from the concern that unbridled competition among employers to pay low wages in construction would lead to a less-skilled and less-productive workforce and to shoddy construction practices and unsafe public buildings and infrastructure.

Attempts to repeal the prevailing wage laws in a number of states are based upon the claim that repeal will save dollars on total construction costs and will bolster state and local budgets. However, there seems to be a disconnect between what the critics of these laws are saying and the reality on the ground. For example, take the case of military veterans. Missing entirely from the debate is the fact that military veterans pursue jobs in the construction trades at substantially higher rates than non-veterans. An estimated half a million veterans are currently employed as construction workers. And this means that any effort to weaken or eliminate these laws would have an outsized impact on veterans. …

Two recent studies, Manzo et al (2016a, 2016b), have analyzed the impact of prevailing wage laws on military veterans. They have found that the economic conditions of veterans would be profoundly affected if states with strong-to-moderate prevailing wage laws were to weaken their standards. The authors showed that prevailing wage laws are vital to all construction worker wages, but are especially crucial for veterans whose post-military service work skews blue collar at a higher rate than other demographics. …

More than 75 percent of recent, peer-reviewed academic studies on this issue have concluded that prevailing wage laws do not increase the total cost of construction. Prevailing wage laws result in higher productivity and taxpayer savings on materials, fuel, and equipment costs. …

These findings in Manzo et al (2016a, 2016b) are consistent with the overwhelming majority of research indicating that the costs of building public structures, such as schools, highways, and street and sewer projects, etc., are unaffected by the presence of municipal, state, or federal prevailing wage laws.

(Read More)

PDF of Study – The Impact of Prevailing Wage Laws on Military Veterans: An Economic and Labor Market Analysis

PDF of Study – The Economic, Fiscal, and Social Impacts of State Prevailing Wage Laws: Choosing Between the High Road and the Low Road in the Construction Industry